The HVAC system is efficient throughout the year, but when something goes wrong, you will have to make a big choice: a repair or a replacement.
Both alternatives have their downsides, and you might feel unwell too. Sometimes you may need to spend a lot of money, which can be pretty stressful. But don’t worry, we’ll give you easy steps and helpful tips to make your choice easier & simpler. This way, you won’t have to guess what to do; you can make an actual decision like the professionals.
- In summer, all sweaty?
- In winter, is everything frozen?
It is homework that is done and covers all that is to be done in times of despair.
We have spent years learning the HVAC system and then practically working with it. We also talked to experts who have fixed and installed these systems many times. Now we want to share our learned information with you.
Why This Decision Matters
The core component of each and every home is the HVAC system (Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning). With the system gone faulty, the house stands to gain:
- Horrible air quality
- A high possibility of having a rise in energy bills
So, while there is a chance to save some money while paying for the upkeep, it is much wiser to replace it over the long term. Making the right call reduces anxiety, keeps the home the way it’s meant to be and, at the same time, saves the homeowner the extra costs.
Step 1: Age of HVAC System
How old is too old? Air conditioners last 10–15 years while furnaces last 15–20 years, depending on usage and maintenance. Older systems tend to lose efficiency, break down, and run on outdated technology that is very costly.
- Quick tip: The chassis on the outside of the furnace in the basement is the best place to start. The Chill Brothers can also help figure this out for you.
What It Means
- Under 10 years: The better choice is to repair unless the structure is heavily damaged.
- 10–15 years: Start comparing repair costs and replacement costs.
- Over 15 years: As parts become more difficult to find, it is usually smarter to replace them.
Real World Example: Jane from Texas had a 12-year-old AC that kept freezing up. The $500 repair cost was recuperated through a new energy-efficient unit. She would have wished to replace it earlier.
Step 2: Evaluate Repair Costs
50% Rule
Simply decide using the 50% rule: If the repair costs are greater than half the cost of a brand new system, it is usually better to do a replacement. For instance, if an HVAC system costs $8,000, as long as the repairs are $4,000 or greater, it would be wise to consider replacement.
Repairs and Costs
- Compressor Failure: $1,000–$2,500 (approx)
- Refrigerant Leak: $200–$1,500 (approx)
- Blower Motor: $300–$900 (approx)
Key Questions
- How often do you call the technician? If the technician is contacted several times in a single financial year, these costs quickly become a large sum.
- Is the fix a band-aid? Band-aid solutions usually do not solve larger problems that an old system may have.
- Is part of the system obsolete? Older machines are often restricted to a smaller number of repairable systems, significantly increasing the cost of repair.
Tip: Request a detailed repair quote and ask the contractor if the repair guarantees more than one or two years of performance.
Step 3: Check Energy Efficiency
Why Efficiency Matters
Older HVAC systems (particularly those prior to 2010) tend to be much less efficient, meaning much higher energy utility costs. For air conditioners, we measure this with something called SEER. For heaters, we use AFUE. These are just fancy ways to say “how much energy does this system waste?”.
- SEER Example: An AC unit with a SEER rating of 8 will cost significantly more to operate than a unit produced today with a SEER rating of 16 and above.
- Savings Potential: Upgrading to a high-efficiency unit can reduce energy utility costs by 20 to 40%, which translates to hundreds of dollars saved in a year.
How to Check
- Look at your energy utility costs. Have they increased even with normal HVAC usage?
- What is your system’s SEER/AFUE (label on unit)? Go and compare these numbers to the current market standards (SEER 14+ for AC, AFUE 90%+ for furnaces).
- Use online calculators or consult with an HVAC professional to get a rough estimate of what you might be able to save with a new system.
Case Study: Mike in Florida saved a significant amount of money by replacing his old AC with a new AC whose SEER rating is 18. Mike reports that his summer electricity bill went down from $300 to $180 per month. That means Mike saved $1,440 during the summer months!
Step 4: Take Into Account Comfort and Air Quality
Temperature is only one element of comfort.
Old HVAC systems “work” but often cannot maintain the desired level of comfort in the home. They may also result in unacceptably poor indoor air quality, which may trigger allergic reactions or stuffiness.
Changes in Behaviour or Malfunction Indications:
- Difference in temperature levels in particular areas (some areas are too warm, while some are too cold)
- Overcycling (turns on and off too frequently)
- Dust and other pollutants in the air
New System Benefits:
- Better humidity control
- Advanced filtration for cleaner air
- Quieter operation
Reader Tip: If family members are sneezing more or your home feels muggy, a new system with modern features could solve these issues.
Step 5: Think About the Costs and Benefits Over Time
Pros and Cons of Repairs:
- Pros:
- Less money up front
- Fix it faster (same day vs. days for a new one)
- Works well for newer systems that have small problems
- Less money up front
- Cons:
- Only a temporary fix for old systems
- More breakdowns are possible
- More expensive energy bills
- Only a temporary fix for old systems
Change: Good and Bad
- Good things:
- Long-term savings on repairs and energy
- Better comfort and air quality
- Warranties that last 5 to 10 years
- Long-term savings on repairs and energy
- Cons:
- Higher initial cost ($5,000–$12,000 depending on the system)
- It takes time to install
- You might need to get financing
- Higher initial cost ($5,000–$12,000 depending on the system)
Trick to Save Money: Check to see if there are any tax credits or rebates for systems that use less energy. Look for deals in your area by calling your local utility companies or going to sites like The Chill Brothers.
Step 6: Seek Expert Guidance
The Reasons for Needing an Expert
There are many reasons to call an expert, as the most important is not knowing what to do. However, there are other things that an expert can easily do, and you can’t(in most cases):
An expert will look at your system thoroughly and find the problem
- He will tell you how much it would cost to fix
- Will suggest a new system as an alternative that you can buy instead of repairing the old system
- Make sure the new system matches the exact size of your space
- Will let you know how much you will save on replacement and repairment
How to Pick an Expert
- Seek out reputable, insured, and licensed businesses.
- Request a thorough analysis of the costs of replacement versus repair.
- Steer clear of “cheap” fixes from unreliable technicians, as they frequently result in more serious issues.
Step of Action: Arrange a consultation with a respectable business. Many provide low-cost or free inspections.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I determine whether it makes sense to repair my HVAC system?
A: Repair is probably acceptable if the system is less than ten years old, repairs cost less than half of the price of a new system, and malfunctions are uncommon. If not, consider replacing.
Can I just replace the furnace or the air conditioner?
A: Yes, but it’s best to use complementary parts (e.g., same brand or efficiency). If a partial replacement makes sense, a professional can offer advice.
How much time does it take to replace?
A: Usually one to three days, depending on how your house is set up and how complicated the system is.
Is it worthwhile to invest in new HVAC systems?
A: Yes, for older systems. Within five to seven years, comfort, energy savings, and fewer repairs frequently outweigh the initial cost.
What to Do Next
Here is a quick checklist to help you make a decision:
- Determine the age of your system by looking at the label or consulting an expert.
- Obtain a quote for repairs and contrast it with the price of replacement.
- To determine whether inefficiency is costing you money, look at your energy bills.
- Assess comfort: Are you satisfied with the air quality and temperature in your home?
- For a personalized recommendation, speak with an HVAC specialist.
Final Words
Deciding whether to replace or repair your HVAC system doesn’t have to be difficult. You can make an informed decision that keeps your house comfortable and your budget happy. That can be done just by looking at your system’s age, repair costs, efficiency, and comfort. When you’re prepared to consider your options, get professional guidance from a reliable source like The Chill Brothers.
Also Read-